I thought it might be a good idea to list the products I've found that I think are better than non-natural alternatives:
Toiletries
Shampoo: Acure Organics Moroccan Argan Oil + Argan Stem Cell Shampoo
Conditioner: Acure Organics Moroccan Argan Oil + Argan Stem Cell Shampoo
Hair Oil: haven't found a good one, still using Moroccan Oil**
Face Wash: Organic Gamcho Cleansing Oil
Light Lotion: Pritte Moisturizing Body Lotion*
Heavy Lotion: Jamu Certified Organic Ginger Oil*
Hand Lotion: SheaTerra Methe Cardamom Wipped Shea Butter
Cosmetics
Eye Shadow Primer: still using up old products
Eye Shadow: still using up old products
Eye Liner: Josie Maran eye liner
Mascara: haven't found a good one (I do not like the Physician's Formula Organic Wear line)
Blush: still using up old products (I do not like any of the Josie Maran blush products I've tried)
Lipstick: Origins Sparkling Punch
Other
Laudry Detergent: homemade
* Products I found through Yuzen, a subscription service I've had a very good experience with. They have not compensated me in any way for this statement (they don't even know who I am).
** This is a product that contains chemicals I would rather not use, if I could find a viable alternative.